Starship Troopers - re:View
Why Hacker News recommends it
Pointed to as a good analysis of the film's satire and layers when Starship Troopers or Heinlein come up.
What it is
Mike and Jay of RedLetterMedia discuss Starship Troopers, covering its legacy, why people like or dislike it, and its reading as sci-fi action satire versus the Heinlein book.
Recommended by 2 HN commenters across 2 different months, 2018 to 2022.
What Hacker News said
Recommends dmreedy · 2018-11 · on “The Predictions of Robert A. Heinlein, from the Cold War to the Waterbed”
I think there's more depth to the film than you might be giving it credit for. There's a lot of goofy heavy-handedness on the surface, but there are some layers underneath, in the writing and the arcs of the characters The guys at Red Letter Media did a pretty good breakdown of it[0] all in all. But even just consider the scene in the beginning when Rasczak is teaching the class about citizenship[1]. It's goofy and funny on the meta-level, because, well, it's Michael Ironside, and he's saying things that at first pass sound insane . But there's a whole lot in that dialog, and it's all played deadly straight. And then compare Rico's genuine, "I don't know" there, to where his character is at
Recommends progre · 2022-03 · on “Notes on Nationalism (1945)”
The book (one of my favourites) is a little diffrent. There the perspective is that of the mobile infantist. The classic hero arc but in a fashist world. Like in the movie, there is no enlightenment or revolution though, just the story of a regular directionless Joe who finds his true self and a purpose in life in the Mobile Infantry. The movie is brilliant in a diffrent way. It's basically satire on all levels. Paul Verhoeven claimed he hated the book and didn't finish it. Red Letter Media has a very good analyis of the whole thing: [this video] "How do you tell your actor that you cast them as a joke?"
Cites savanaly · 2020-07 · on “How “Starship Troopers” Aligns with Our Moment of American Defeat”
I haven't seen it but I know it was featured on Red Letter Media's re:View series where they review movies they actually like [0]. Especially at the start they discuss its legacy and why people like/hate it. [0] [this video]