"Debate" American Style: Our Top Orators in Action
Why Hacker News recommends it
Used as a cited example in threads criticizing the direction of competitive school and college debate.
What it is
A short clip from the 2014 college debate championship, posted by a commentator who criticizes the winning performance as not being a real debate. It shows a fast, unconventional style of competitive debate.
Recommended by 0 HN commenters across 0 different months, 2017 to 2023.
What Hacker News said
Critical jackhack · 2017-10 · on “The Corrosion of High School Debate”
If anyone has a doubt as to how far "debate" has fallen, this should be an eye-opening case-in-point: [this video] [edit: Flagged? Really?? - this video exposes the very absurdity discussed in the article. A Championship debate team doing what few educated persons would recognize or identify as debate.]
Critical powertower · 2017-10 · on “The Corrosion of High School Debate”
I don't know how bad it is at the high school level, but it does get worse as you go up to the University level... For an example, take the 2014 CEDA Championship Debate held at Indiana University - [this video] * It seems that all the original videos from the above have been removed (from youtube), only clips are available. For those that are interested, a response to the criticism of the above "debate" was made that is itself cringe-worthy and difficult to watch - [LINK]
Critical nnfy · 2017-10 · on “The Corrosion of High School Debate”
I dont know if it is acceptable to post YouTube links on HN, but here is a recording of recent national champions.[1] That it is even called debate is tragic. 1. [this video]
Critical logicalmonster · 2023-06 · on “At High School Debates, Watch What You Say”
I don't know much about debating competitions, but I was floored when I saw this video when researching this. [this video] If this is real and not a parody, it seems like whatever scoring system they use incentivizes the wrong behavior even before you get into idealogical debates.
Critical livinginfear · 2023-07 · on “How critical theory is radicalizing high school debate”
I remember seeing this video a while ago: [this video] Is this actually indicative of the kind of structured debate that happens in colleges?